Employers losing focus on inclusive hiring, suggests annual survey of employers

There is a disappointing decline in the number of employers who are using best practice methods for inclusive hiring, suggests an annual survey of employers by the Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC).

It is a major concern if employers are failing to understand the commercial and ethical reasons to ensure they hire inclusively, especially given the UK’s acute skills and labour shortages and long-standing struggles to up productivity. The findings will also alarm job seekers from minority or underrepresented groups who may be struggling to get on in their careers.

The survey also shows how vital it is for recruiters to continue to challenge their clients to embrace diversity as a way of opening up talent pools and innovation.

Key findings in the 2024 survey:

• A total of 55.2% of employers surveyed said they do not specifically state an interest in diverse candidates in their job adverts. The figure was 49.2% in 2023 and 47.9% in 2022. And just 5.8% plan to implement this in the future, which compares to 7.2% in 2023 and 8.2% in 2022. But at least 25.5% said they introduced this more than a year ago – up on 23.8% in 2023 but down on the 29.2% in 2022.
• And 44.2% of those surveyed do not use wording specifically designed to be inclusive in their job adverts, compared to 28.3% who did not in 2023 and 33.0% who did not in 2022. And just 3.8% plan to implement this in the future, compared to 5.4% in 2023 who said they planned to and 5.0% in 2022 who said they planned to.
• A total of 74.8% do not use name blind CV submissions, compared to 69.9% who did not in 2023 and 53.2% who did not in 2022. While 3.8% said in 2024 they plan on implementing this in the future which is up in comparison to the 1.4% who said in 2023 they would implement it, it is lower than the 7.3% who said in 2022 they planned to implement it.
• Finally, a total of 61.7% of surveyed employers said they do not use diverse interview panels, which is more than the 55.7% in 2023 and 53.4% in 2022 who said they did not use them. In better news, 11.5% said they plan to implement this in the future, compared to 10.6% in 2023 and 8.3% in 2022.

Neil Carberry, REC Chief Executive, said:

“While the labour market has weakened over the past two years, the UK‘s labour supply is still tight, and new skills needs are making traditional hiring methods less effective. This survey suggests that many employers still think of inclusive hiring as something to do in the better times – rather than a fundamental to being able to hire well in the mid-2020s. With productivity and engagement critical to innovation and growth, a new approach is necessary.

“Recruiters who meet the REC’s compliance standards are the experts in building new talent pools up, but they report that hiring managers are not as willing to think about different options now.  Despite the unhelpful political framing of work on diverse and inclusive hiring as somehow “woke”, getting this right is both a commercial and a fairness issue. Business leaders need to understand that, even in a cooling market, the world has changed and engaging with a wide pool of potential employees requires a new approach. Recruiters are ready to help.”

As an additional question for this year’s survey, REC asked these same employers what would most encourage their organisations to implement or enhance EDI practices in their recruitment process. The most sought for help was for training and learning resources on best EDI practices (29%), stronger internal policies and commitment from senior leaders at their respective organisation (26%), events and networking with other organisations on EDI initiatives (20%) and support and advice from external EDI experts (17%).

Neil Carberry said:

“Recruiters sit at the heart of coming up with guidance, training and solutions for firms on workplace equality, diversity, and inclusion. This includes everything from neuroinclusive recruitment to building workplaces where people of all races, sexual orientations and genders feel welcome. But it is clear from today’s survey that they need greater commitment from business leaders. This includes greater understanding and backing from their clients’ Boards and executives that their firms can get more creative, innovative and profitable when they attract, hire and retain the best talent.”

Notes to editors

REC commissioned pollsters Savanta to ask 167 employers in the UK of different sizes and locations by telephone in August, about their use of certain measures in their recruitment process. It is the third such annual survey of employers carried out by REC. The same number of different employers were surveyed in 2023 and 2022.

Labour Market Tracker: Late summer hiring in tourism and hospitality keeps job ad numbers solid – REC – 16 September 2024. The number of overall active postings in August 2024 was 1,719,614 and there were 719,721 new job postings in August 2024.

The REC publishes advice, guidance, training and events to promote best practice in hiring when it comes to EDI. For more information visit Our latest advice on equality, diversity and inclusion. For example, our Unlock the power of inclusive recruitment guide help recruiters to:

• Create and develop an EDI strategy and action plan that works for your business
• Establish and improve partnerships with your clients
• Win and retain high margin business
• Attract and retain top talent for your recruitment business
• Source exceptional candidates for your clients

Click here to view all REC press releases and for more information and interview enquiries, contact the REC Press Office on 020 7009 2157, 020 7009 2129 or pressoffice@rec.uk.com. Outside of regular office hours, please call 07702 568 829.

The REC is the voice of the recruitment industry, speaking up for great recruiters. We drive standards and empower recruitment businesses to build better futures for great candidates and themselves. We are champions of an industry which is fundamental to the strength of the UK economy.

Find out more about the Recruitment & Employment Confederation at www.rec.uk.com.

​