Is the Gender Pay Gap narrative hurting young women

This is a guest blog by REC business partner Wotter

UK women are experiencing a remarkable surge in workplace happiness, according to Wotter data. Employee sentiment has skyrocketed, with women reporting significant improvements across nearly all aspects of their work lives. Their overall workplace happiness has surged by 74.46 points, far outpacing men's 11.90-point increase. However, a glaring exception exists: financial wellbeing. While women thrive in other areas, their financial wellbeing scores have dipped by -0.78 points, while men's have risen by +1.34. This disconnect raises critical questions about the factors influencing women's perceived financial security.

Generational disparities and the money puzzle

The situation becomes more complex when examining generational trends. Data from the House of Commons* indicates that the gender pay gap is most pronounced among Baby Boomer and Gen X women. Yet, contrary to expectations, Baby Boomer women saw a +4.94 point improvement in financial wellbeing. Gen Z women, who supposedly face the least pay disparity, experienced a -4.05 point drop, while Millennial women also saw a decrease (-1.06). Gen X women saw a small increase of +0.80. Men's scores followed a different pattern, with Baby Boomers and Gen X seeing increases, Millennials a slight decrease, and Gen Z also seeing an increase. This generational divergence challenges obvious assumptions about the relationship between pay gaps and financial wellbeing.

Is the Gender Pay Gap narrative impacting morale?

These findings raise a crucial question: is the constant messaging about the gender pay gap negatively impacting younger women's morale, even when they may not be experiencing it to the same extent? If young women are consistently told they will earn less than their male peers, could this be shaping their financial perceptions, regardless of actual pay parity? This suggests that perceived financial insecurity may be influencing their outlook.

What employers should do

Employers with young female staff should prioritise transparent communication about pay equity. Emphasise that pay parity exists within the organisation, reinforcing the message that women are valued and compensated fairly. This is key, because a fair paycheque only has positive effects if the employee believes it is fair.

While women currently demonstrate high levels of workplace engagement, their financial concerns could escalate. Employers must proactively address this disconnect to prevent future disengagement. By fostering transparency and providing adequate support, organisations can ensure women continue to thrive.

The bottom line: Addressing the financial disconnect

Women are happier at work than before, but financial wellbeing progress is lagging. Employers must act to bridge this gap, ensuring that women's financial perceptions align with their overall positive workplace experiences. 

While these insights are averaged across our entire dataset, individual organisations who use Wotter can see these trends on their own employees and may find vastly different trends. Financial wellbeing is 1 of 24 engagement pillars that are measured and analysed by Wotter’s automated survey tool and offers a real time insight into where leadership teams need to pay attention.

Learn more about Wotter